====== Early Arrangements ====== Cobs 1-47+ and 101-234+ have an early arrangement often characterized by additional melody [[:octaves]]. It is conjectured that the earliest rollers (cobs) were arranged for pressure instruments, and upon the change to vacuum it was determined that an arrangement with fewer concurrent notes would be preferable. In addition, [[:pinning]] are also common. It is often possible to recognize Early Arrangements by their [[:labels]]. *Front Labels: *All known cobs which have labels with a wide "**N O.**" (with a slight space between the letters) are Early Arrangements. *Later labels have "**NO.**" without the space; these may //possibly// be Early Arrangements. *No known Early Arrangements have the late "**No.**" labels. *Directions Labels: *Early labels have two-sentence Directions; these may //possibly// be Early Arrangements. *Later labels have a single sentence; these may //possibly// be Early Arrangements but it is very unlikely. *No known Early Arrangements have late directions labels with "emblems" above the text. \\ **Early roller (cob) features in contrast to later editions:** //(Unlisted titles are not yet known.)// ^No. - Name^[[:labels]]^Doubled Octaves^Lower Key^Extra Notes^Stretch((The individual notes can differ in length (a different number of pins). Cobs with mostly longer notes are considered to be //stretched// in comparison.))^Wood Finish((Earlier cobs usually have a glossy finish, although it's often difficult to tell. Later cobs are usually plain wood.))^Comments ^ |[[:cobs:1:]] |N O./NO. |Y|N|Y|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:2:]] |NO. |-|Y, 4th | | |Y|earliest | |//(2nd arrangement)// |NO. |Y|N|N|longer |Y|still "early" | |[[:cobs:3:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:4:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|shorter |Y|3rd "almost early" has one more note than "late" | |[[:cobs:5:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y| |Y| | |[[:cobs:6:]] |NO. |Y, few |N|Y|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:8:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:9:]] |N O. |Y|N|harmony change |N|Y| | |[[:cobs:10:]] |N O./NO. |Y|N|Y|some shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:11:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|slight |Y| | |[[:cobs:12:]] |NO. |Y|N|harmony change |N|Y| | |[[:cobs:13:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|slight |Y| | |[[:cobs:14:]] |N O. |-|Y, 4th |Y| |Y|3rd "late" exists, with a few octaves added | |[[:cobs:15:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:16:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|N|Y|/*late version found 1/8/2008*/ | |[[:cobs:17:]] |?|Y|N|Y| |Y| | |[[:cobs:18:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|N|Y|pauses between phrases | |[[:cobs:20:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:21:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:22:]] |?|Y|N|N|N|Y|3rd "late" has original melody octave | |[[:cobs:23:]] |NO. |Y|N|harmony change |shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:24:]] | |Y|N|N|slight |Y| | |[[:cobs:25:]] |N O. |Y|N|N| |Y| | |[[:cobs:26:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|slight |Y| | |[[:cobs:27:]] |?|Y|N|N|longer gaps |Y| | |[[:cobs:28:]] |N O. |-|Y, 4th | | |Y| | |[[:cobs:29:]] |NO. |-|Y, 4th | | |Y|"early" has sustained harmony notes | |[[:cobs:30:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y|some shorter |Y|"late" has sustained harmony notes | |[[:cobs:31:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|slight |Y| | |[[:cobs:32:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|N| | |[[:cobs:35:]] |NO. |Y|N|N| |Y| | |[[:cobs:36:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:41:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:42:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:43:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|very slight|Y| | |[[:cobs:47:]] |?|Y|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:101:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y, many changed |shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:102:]] |N O. |-|Y, 4th | | |Y|3rd "late" w/ very slight differences | |[[:cobs:103:]] |N O., patent stamp |Y|N|Y, much fuller |longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:104:]] |N O. |Y|N|harmony change |longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:105:]] |NO. |Y|N|more of tune | |Y|much faster, ending is longer/repeated | |[[:cobs:106:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|some shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:107:]] |N O., no patent |Y|N|N|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:108:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|longer notes |Y|some changed octaves/notes | |[[:cobs:109:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:110:]] |N O. |Y|N| | | |black/gold label | |[[:cobs:111:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y, changes |some shorter |Y|red label, but early large-diameter core | |[[:cobs:112:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y, changes | |Y| | |[[:cobs:113:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:115:]] |?|Y|N|Y|shorter |Y|8 single stray pins (highest note) at start of every measure | |[[:cobs:116:]] |N O. |N|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:117:]] |?| | | | | |/*early version found 1/19/2008*/ | |[[:cobs:118:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|shorter |Y|both shorter and longer notes | |[[:cobs:120:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|longer |Y|"early" has some longer harmony notes | |[[:cobs:121:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y|longer notes |Y|some sustained | |[[:cobs:122:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|shorter |Y|3rd has shorter bass, melody jumps to higher octave | |[[:cobs:123:]] |NO. |Y|N, see note |Y, few |longer |Y|3rd "late" is 5th higher, moving notes in harmony | |[[:cobs:124:]] | |Y|N|Y|longer |Y|/*Bob and Cathy Gunter*/ | |[[:cobs:125:]] |N O. |-|-|-|-|-|late change | |[[:cobs:126:]] | |Y|N|Y|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:127:]] |N O., patent stamp |Y|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:128:]] |N O., patent stamp |Y|N|N| |Y| | |[[:cobs:129:]] |N O., patent stamp |Y|N|Y, few |longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:130:]] |N O., patent stamp |Y|N|Y|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:131:]] |N O. | | | | | |/*late version found 1/19/2008*/ | |[[:cobs:132:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|slight |Y |/*late version found 2012*/ | |[[:cobs:133:]] |NO. |N|N|Y|slight |Y|/*late version found 2012*/ | |[[:cobs:134:]] | |Y|N|Y|shorter |Y|3rd "late" adds octaves back in! | |[[:cobs:135:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|some longer | | | |[[:cobs:136:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|N|Y|some sustained notes, rather than repeated staccato | |[[:cobs:137:]] |?|Y|N|N|shorter |N| | |[[:cobs:138:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|some shorter |Y|3rd has different octaves, notes | |[[:cobs:139:]] |N O. | | | | | |/*late version found 1/19/2008*/ | |[[:cobs:140:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|longer |Y|some sustained, marked "Play Slowly" | |[[:cobs:141:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y|slight |Y| | |[[:cobs:142:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y|some longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:143:]] |N O., patent stamp |Y|N|N|? |Y|/*early version found 2/16/2008*/ | |[[:cobs:144:]] |N O. |Y|N|harmony change |N|Y|harmony has more beats | |[[:cobs:145:]] |?|Y|N|Y|some notes longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:146:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y|N|N|some note changes | |[[:cobs:147:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|slight |Y| | |[[:cobs:148:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:149:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y, much fuller |longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:150:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:151:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y, few |shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:152:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y, few |shorter |N|3rd "almost early" with very slight difference | |[[:cobs:153:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|some shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:154:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:155:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y, few |some shorter |Y|ending is shorter/truncated | |[[:cobs:156:]] |N O./NO. |Y|N|Y|longer |Y|3rd "late" slightly different | |[[:cobs:157:]] |NO. |N|N|N|shorter |N|slight, different octaves, last note not held | |[[:cobs:158:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|N|N| | |[[:cobs:159:]] | |Y|N|Y|N|Y|/*Bob and Cathy Gunter*/ | |[[:cobs:161:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|N|3rd "almost early" has much longer notes | |[[:cobs:162:]] |?|?|Y|N|N|N| | |[[:cobs:163:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y, few |some longer |N| | |[[:cobs:164:]] |N O. |N|N|N|some longer |Y|staccato harmony | |[[:cobs:165:]] |?|Y|N|N|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:166:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|some longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:167:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|some shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:170:]] |N O. |N|N|N|some longer |N|only stretched | |[[:cobs:172:]] |N O. |Y|N|Y|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:173:]] |N O. | | | | |Y|late version not yet found | |[[:cobs:174:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:175:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:176:]] |N O. | | | | |Y|late version not yet found | |[[:cobs:179:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:180:]] |N O. | | | | |Y|late version not yet found | |[[:cobs:181:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:183:]] |N O. |Y|N|N|some longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:185:]] |N O. | | | | | |late version not yet found | |[[:cobs:186:]] |N O. | | | | | |late version not yet found | |[[:cobs:187:]] |N O. | | | | | |late version not yet found | |[[:cobs:188:]] |N O. | | | | | |late version not yet found | |[[:cobs:190:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|order |Y|verse, chorus repeat in different order | |[[:cobs:191:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:194:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y, few |N|Y| | |[[:cobs:196:]] |?|Y|N|intro |N|Y|intro, faster | |[[:cobs:199:]] |?|N|N|Y, few |some shorter |N| | |[[:cobs:200:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|Y|staccato | |[[:cobs:201:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:202:]] |NO. |N|N|N|some shorter |Y|some held | |[[:cobs:203:]] |NO. |Y, few |N|few different |shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:204:]] |NO. |N|N|N|longer |N|staccato | |[[:cobs:205:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|longer |N|staccato | |[[:cobs:206:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|some shorter |Y| | |[[:cobs:207:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|Y|some staccato | |[[:cobs:209:]] |NO. |Y|Y|N|N|N|shorter | |[[:cobs:212:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|Y|some longer, some shorter | |[[:cobs:213:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y, few |longer |Y| | |[[:cobs:216:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|some shorter|Y| | |[[:cobs:217:]] |NO. |N|N|Y, few |longer |N| | |[[:cobs:218:]] |NO. |N|N|One changed |N|N|a few holds are different | |[[:cobs:221:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|shorter |N|long last note | |[[:cobs:222:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|N| | |[[:cobs:224:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|N| /*early version found 2/4/2008*/ | |[[:cobs:226:]] |NO. |Y|N|Y|N|Y| | |[[:cobs:229:]] |?|Y|N|N|N|N| | |[[:cobs:230:]] |NO. |N|N|Y, few |N|N| | |[[:cobs:232:]] |NO. |N|N|Y, few |N|N| | |[[:cobs:234:]] |NO. |Y|N|N|N|N|sustained notes |